Actuarial High Risk Tier

5 Most Expensive Cars to Insure

Premiums Exceed $4,200/yr 2.8x • National Average Multiplier

Exotic aluminum chassis, high-theft badges, and specialized technician labor rates create staggering insurance rates for these 5 vehicles.

Underwriting Drivers

Why Supercars Drain Wallets

High Severity + Theft +$140/hr • Certified Body Labor

Carriers charge double because carbon fiber repairs, specialized tooling, and high-frequency theft claims inflate total payout severity.

Rank #1 • Highest Overall

Maserati Ghibli

$4,280 / year $357/mo • National Average

Rapid depreciation paired with exorbitant Ferrari-derived parts costs and scarce authorized body shops make the Ghibli #1 in actuarial risk.

Rank #2 • High Theft Target

Dodge Charger Hellcat

$4,190 / year 6.4x • Theft Relativity Score

The Highway Loss Data Institute reports Hellcat models are stolen 64 times more frequently than average vehicles, driving colossal comprehensive rates.

Rank #3 • Rear-Engine Legend

Porsche 911 Carrera

$3,980 / year $332/mo • National Average

Despite superior driver demographics, aluminum unibody repair rates and specialized radar alignment create heavy collision loss costs.

Rank #4 • German Supercoupe

BMW M8 Competition

$3,890 / year $324/mo • National Average

With 617 twin-turbo horsepower, carbon fiber roof panels, and laser headlights costing $4,500 each, any front collision results in massive payouts.

Rank #5 • Electric Rocket

Tesla Model S Plaid

$3,720 / year 1,020 HP • Instant Electric Torque

Sub-2-second acceleration increases at-fault collision frequency, while high-voltage battery replacement costs exceed $18,000 upon impact.

Interactive Quiz

Theft Risk Leader

Test Your Knowledge
Deductible Optimization

Raising to $2,500

High-Net-Worth Strategy -22% • Annual Premium Reduction

High-performance owners can raise collision deductibles from $500 to $2,500, immediately cutting annual premiums by over $800.

View Full 196-Vehicle Risk Rankings